“Crash Site Confidential” – The NTSB Photographs Of Southern Airways Flight 242 – by Clifford Davids

Southern Airways DC-9

Southern Airways fleet of 404’s in Atlanta, GA (Photo ca. 1972)

The National Transportation Safety Board is an American icon. Everyone recognizes their intrepid investigators, clad in navy blue shirts emblazoned with the yellow “NTSB” logo, swarming all over the horrific wreckage of airplanes, ships, and trains. Established in 1967, the Board is mandated by the U. S. Government to conduct independent investigations into every type of accident on land, air, and sea. Their final recommendations will often result in significant changes to the existing transportation safety regulations.

In 1977, the NTSB investigated and issued findings on a multitude of commercial aircraft crashes in the United States. One of their investigations involved the crash of Southern Airways Flight 242 in New Hope, Georgia on April 4, 1977. They fully documented the accident scene, examining everything from the recovered cockpit voice recorder to the severely damaged engines to the performance of the flight crew. Their final report was issued on January 26, 1978, and included the following majority opinion:

“The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of this accident was the total and unique loss of thrust from both engines while the aircraft was penetrating an area of severe thunderstorms. The loss of thrust was caused by the ingestion of massive amounts of water and hail which in combination with thrust lever movement induced severe stalling in and major damage to the engine compressors.”

“Major contributing factors included the failure of the company’s dispatching system to provide the flight crew with up-to-date severe weather data pertaining to the aircraft’s intended route of flight, the captain’s reliance on airborne weather radar for penetration of thunderstorm areas, and limitations in the Federal Aviation Administration’s air traffic control system which precluded the timely dissemination of real-time hazardous weather information to the flight crew.”

Francis McAdams was the only Safety Board member who dissented from the majority opinion. He submitted the following assessment:

“The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of this accident involves the captain’s decision to penetrate rather than avoid an area of severe weather, the failure to obtain all of the available weather information despite having prior knowledge of the severity of the storm system, and the reliance upon airborne weather radar for penetration rather than avoidance of the storm system. The penetration resulted in a total loss of thrust from both engines due to the ingestion of massive amounts of water and hail which in combination with advanced throttle settings induced severe stalling in, and major damage to, the engine compressors, which prevented the crew from restarting the engines.”

“Furthermore, if the company’s dispatching system had provided the flight crew with timely severe weather information pertaining to the aircraft’s intended route of flight, it is possible that the severe weather would not have been penetrated.”

“Contributing to the cause were the inadequacies of the FAA’s air traffic control system which precluded the timely dissemination of real-time hazardous weather information to the flight crew.”

The Damaged Engines

Directly after the crash in New Hope, the NTSB removed Flight 242’s engines to a secure hangar owned by Southern Airways in Atlanta, GA. After an investigation of the engine’s components, the Safety Board reported the following:

“The NTSB concludes that after rotational speed was first lost (due to the ingestion of large quantities of water), the throttles were advanced, and surging and stalling occurred which caused the blades in the low-pressure compressors to clash against the vanes. This conclusion is supported by the physical damage to the engines.”

“The damage to both low-pressure compressors indicates that the sixth-stage blades deflected forward, clashed with the fifth-stage stator vanes, and broke pieces from the blades and vanes. Pieces of the vanes and blades were then ingested into the high-pressure compressors, causing extreme damage to these compressors.”

“The Safety Board further concludes that the lack of typical foreign object damage, including hail damage from known encounters, to the fan blades and the blades in the forward stages of the low-pressure compressors clearly indicates that hail ingestion was not responsible for the compressor damage. Following the damage to the compressors and turbines the engines were no longer capable of producing thrust.”

The federal investigators also created a photographic record in the aftermath of the crash. The nine pictures posted below were taken by photographer Warren L. Bond, and they provide a powerful impact statement more visceral than any description contained in the written report. I would like to to submit these images for the public record.

——————————

The Southern Airways Flight 242 Crash Site

 – New Hope, GA –

Straight-on view of the Flight 242 forced landing site on Dallas-Acworth Highway in New Hope, GA

The forced landing site on Highway 92 Spur. The volunteer fire station (with a pole-mounted siren) is the red building at the bottom. The remains of Newman’s Store are mid-photo. The aircraft’s final resting site is at the top.

—————————–

An aerial view of Flight 242′s final resting site

An aerial view of Flight 242′s final resting site

—————————–

The crash site in New Hope, GA

Investigators examine the crash site in New Hope, GA

——————————

The crash site

The burned remnants of Southern Airways Flight 242

——————————

The remains of the cockpit

The partial remains of instrument panel from Southern Airways Flight 242

——————————

The remnants of the tail section. The separated right wing is in the foreground.

The broken tail section. The separated right wing is in the foreground.

——————————

The remains of Southern Airways Flight 242

The remains of the pilots’ cabin and forward galley of Southern Airways Flight 242

——————————

Side view of the mid-section of the fuselage and left engine. The tail section is in the background.

Side view of the mid-section of the fuselage and left engine. The tail section is in the background.

——————————

Side view of the right engine next to the fuselage

Side view of the right engine next to the fuselage

 – Photographs courtesy of Warren L. Bond –

——————————

Advertisements
This entry was posted in The Tragic Crash of Southern Airways Flight 242 and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

29 Responses to “Crash Site Confidential” – The NTSB Photographs Of Southern Airways Flight 242 – by Clifford Davids

  1. Cheryl G says:

    Wow–I can’t believe I never knew about this before. Great pics!

  2. Robin says:

    Incredible photos. Plus, I am astounded that anyone can make sense of the wreckage. Heartbreaking and difficult to view knowing so many died.

  3. sandra hite says:

    I have lived in New Hope, GA for forty two years, and I remember this as if it were just yesterday. I had friends on the ground who died in this horrible crash along with their children. Tell your family that you love them because they may not be here tomorrow.

  4. Wesley says:

    I remember that day very well…

  5. R Davis says:

    Mr. Davids,
    Thank you for this interesting story and info on the plane crash. I am from this area but was just a youngster then. It’s interesting now to read the details that fill in the gaps of all the stories about the crash I have heard over the years.

    Your other entries on the letters from the civil war also caught my eye. You may already know this, but the Battle of New Hope Church was fought a literal stone’s throw away, just across the road and through the thin veil of trees from where that plane crashed. If you happen to not be familiar with it, research the term “The Hell Hole” in relation to Sherman’s passing through this area on the way to Atlanta on his “March to the Sea”–it refers to the fierce fighting at that battlefield.

    Today there are several markers, monuments and graves in the area to commemorate the battle and associated events there. Pickett’s Mill is just a few miles up the highway from where the plane crashed. Pickett’s Mill Park is now there and they have a history center there with a few artifacts and information about the battle and the other local battles during the war.

    • cbdavids says:

      Thank you for your thoughtful comments. New Hope, GA is a unique place – a rural community in Paulding County that has been the unwilling host to two of Georgia’s most tragic and historic events: the Battle of New Hope Church in May of 1864 and the tragic crash of Southern Airways Flight 242 in April of 1977.

      • R Davis says:

        Thank you. When I made my first comment after reading this story, I had not yet seen your other articles that cover the stories of the Civil War at New Hope, GA.

        I feel sort of silly “informing” you about the Battle of New Hope. That’s one of the pitfalls of the internet, I suppose. One can tend to start reading in the “middle of the book” so to speak, without realizing it. 🙂

        Thank you again for the articles. Very intriguing information.

  6. sam bishop says:

    Etched in my memory forever.

    Sam Bishop
    Director of Security on April 4, 1977
    Kennestone Hospital, Marietta , GA

  7. Gary Mobley says:

    I worked in ATL for Southern on April 4, 1977. These pictures are what a “real” passenger aircraft crash landing looks like. Compare them with what the Pentagon crash on 9/11 looked like and tell me what’s wrong . . .

  8. David Cope says:

    Mr. Davids,
    Thank you very much for the info and pics of this unfortunate tragedy. I had two cousins on this flight, one survived and one did not, although the cousin that survived recently passed away.

    My family is from the Sheffield/Florence/Muscle Shoals area, and we were living in Albany, GA at the time of the crash. I vividly remember my parents telling my brother, sister and myself about what happened, and them traveling to be with my cousin and his family. I purchased a home and moved less than 2 miles away from the crash site in 2005, not realizing how close I was, until reading about the reunion, and then my mother visiting and realizing we are just a few miles away from the place she has visited all those years ago after the crash.

    I try to keep all of the info I find on this, so many thanks.

    David Cope

    • cbdavids says:

      Mr. Cope – Thank you for letting me know about you and your family. I remember hearing that the 30th reunion in 2007 brought together a lot of survivors and families who hadn’t seen each other in many years. I understand that they will also be holding the 37th reunion in 2014, and I hope you and your family will be able to attend.

      • David Cope says:

        Mr. Davids – Thanks for the quick reply. I would like very much to attend, and especially bring my mother, who still lives in Sheffield, and only has come to one reunion. Keep us posted.

  9. Trisha says:

    Paulding Hospital has a wall of photos from that crash. Working there with the elderly, I heard first-hand stories of that horrible crash from people who worked the hospital, lived in the area, or had family involved in the wreck. Paulding Hospital does not have a morgue, but the basement was used as one for the cleanup of the crash.

  10. Darlene Pruett says:

    I worked in the reservations department at Southern Airways back then and was on duty when we got the word of the crash. Almost immediately, calls started coming into the office. Although some were curiosity seekers, many of the calls were from family members of passengers inquiring about their loved ones. It was a haunting experience that I will never forget.

  11. Ric says:

    I was meeting with my Dad who was a Stone Mountain, Georgia, police officer that afternoon. He was sitting in his patrol car door to door with me in my personal car. Suddenly, he stopped talking and began listening to the police radio intently as the DeKalb Police dispatcher began to tell of an major aircraft crash in Paulding County, many miles away. We listened to the police radio as the DeKalb supervisors asked her (the dispatcher) to check with Chief Hand and see if there was a need for DeKalb officers to go to the scene. Moments later, Car 1, Chief Hand, instructed them to have as many cars to be enroute as they could and assist however they were needed.

    Later, I went to my girlfriends home for dinner and together we watched the news as the graphic scene unfolded in Paulding County. I will never forget the day and hearing this as it happened.

    • Barry Woodward says:

      Ric, we went with the DeKalb Police Command Post sometime around 0300 hours to support all of the people we sent to assist, and to assist GSP Command Post who was overwhelmed. In some of the pictures, we are parked to the right of the GSP Post and the tail section. It’s something you never forget.

      • Ric says:

        Barry, DCPD never failed to support and help other departments and the public when a major event like this occurred. They are to be commended and yes, you never forget!

  12. Philip says:

    I live about two miles from the crash site. I wasn’t born until the year after, but I can recall many of the stories told by my dad and grandfather in the years that followed. My dad, who is now a physician, was a pharmacist at the time and was involved with caring for the survivors. He was interviewed in 1997 as part of this NY Times piece:

    http://www.nytimes.com/1997/04/14/us/memories-and-healing-2-decades-after-crash.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm

  13. Valerie says:

    “The young, pony-tailed pharmacist…”
    I remember that guy well.

  14. Phyllis Inzina Reid says:

    Philip-thank you for the link to the article. My father died in that crash when I was only 16 years old.

    Cliff-thank you for your writing and for sharing the pics.

  15. SDF880 says:

    I remember this well, sad. The captain’s son went on to fly for the airline I work for.

    • moms2kool says:

      SDF880, I lost my father in this crash. My husband is a captain with the same airline as you. Would I know you? The son of the captain on Southern 242 is retired now. I have met his mother at one of the memorials. My husband’s flies out of SDF. What plane do you fly?

      • SDF880 says:

        I work in Flight Operations/Dispatch SDF. I know some of our crews and what a great group of folks to work with daily! I had heard captain M retired awhile back. I don’t recall ever talking to him but saw his name on my flight releases. I’m sorry for the loss of your father in SOU242! I study all accidents from every angle and maybe come away with some info to help keep the repeat of accidents such as SOU242 from happening. Back then weather products were not anything like today and rapid communication to the crews really didn’t exist either like it does now. I would like to think SOU 242 and other accidents have helped lead to what we have in place now.

  16. Robert Jaques says:

    My friend Don Foster of from North Alabama was one of the last survivors of this crash. He was one of the lucky ones. My prayers go out to those who did not make it and their families.

  17. Bill says:

    Many times I walked over through those trees to the Burkhalter home as shown in photo 7. The little white house with the low roof belonged to the Poole family. Great article.

  18. Tom Caldwell says:

    My mother was born in New Hope in 1918, and my great-grandfather fought for the CSA during the Battle of New Hope Church and is buried in New Hope cemetery. I passed through the area not much over a month after the crash and the place was clean as a pin. Southern Airways wasted no time at all getting the crash site cleaned up.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s