“To Protect and Defend” – The Legal Maneuverings of James G. Merrimon – by Clifford B. Davids

Grace Green with a new arrival from Faith Cottage

Grace Green showing off a new arrival from Faith Cottage

James Gibbon Merrimon was born into judicial royalty. He was the son of renowned Judge James H. Merrimon, and the nephew of Augustus S. Merrimon, chief justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court. A stalwart member of the Asheville legal community for over six decades and a pit bull in the court room, J.G. Merrimon also had an uncommon passion for flowers, and was proud of his honorary membership in the local garden club.

After he passed at 89 years old in 1948, his obituary discreetly noted that he had served as chief counsel for an unnamed orphanage for many years – a work it was said he performed with quiet devotion. The article stated, “His reward was in the knowledge that he had served the little ones well who had no one else to fight their battles. It was from this work, of which he rarely spoke, that he received some of the greatest satisfaction in his life.” The orphanage referred to in that obituary was Eliada Homes, and its founder was the renowned mountain evangelist Reverend Lucius Bunyan Compton.

Starting in the mid-1930’s, Merrimon handled all of the legal matters for both the orphanage as well as Compton’s rescue home known as “Faith Cottage,” a haven for unmarried girls who were “in the family way.” He provided legal counsel for outstanding issues ranging from from financial bequests to personal injury claims to adoptions. He also represented Compton during his criminal trial in 1943, obtaining an acquittal to the sexual assault charges filed against him regarding four teenage girls living at Eliada.

Grace Green, Compton’s executive assistant who was responsible for running the orphanage in his absence, dealt directly with Merrimon on many of the most sensitive matters involving the children. The situation highlighted below, involving a case of statutory rape committed by a father against his daughter resulting in her pregnancy, was dealt with quickly and quietly by the cautious attorney. It all began with the urgent telegram sent to Merrimon (below), followed by his immediate response.


Merrimon Western Union cropped

Western Union Telegram


July 25, 1945

Miss Grace Green, Eliada Orphanage

R.F.D. Ashville, N.C.

Dear Miss Green:

Mrs. Thomas has shown me the memorandum made when you were in the office this morning regarding the baby and girl at Faith Cottage. I had talked to Mr. Compton about this matter and he promised to get me the name of the man.

Under the common law, any person can change his name at will, without any legal proceeding, by adopting another name. Some states have statutes in regard to making this change and it is said the statutory method has distinct advantages, in that it is definite and constitutes a matter of record which is easily proven even after the death of all contemporaneous witnesses.

An illegitimate baby inherits from the mother, but not from he father–it is her child, and the father is only responsible for its maintenance during minority in such amount as the court might fix. The child would not inherit from the father at all.

In North Carolina, we have a statute about change of name, which says that any person who wishes, for a good cause, to change his name must file an application before the Clerk of the Superior Court of the County in which he lives, having first given ten days notice of the change by publication at the Courthouse door and in his application the reason for desiring the change must be given, must show good character, etc. The Clerk then grants the Order making the change and the person is entitled to all the privileges and protection under the new name. He can’t change his name but once under the statute.

There is no reason why this girl can’t, if she leaves here, take any name she pleases so far as I know, provided she lives in North Carolina. The baby takes her name anyway, whatever it is. That is the only name it has. I suppose a birth certificate was given and this birth certificate would have to show the name of the mother and father. All persons are required to have birth certificates and the doctor’s duty is to furnish it. He is guilty of a misdemeanor if he does not. It might be forwarded to the Department in Raleigh. I don’t know of any provision in North Carolina that enables birth certificates to be withheld. I want to take this matter up with the Solicitor, if I can.

The birth of every child must be registered. General Statutes 130-85, etc. This certificate must be filed within five days after the birth, and it is the duty of the physician or the mid-wife to file it. The contents of the birth certificate are set forth in great detail, and it is required that all institutions shall keep records of such persons.

I will talk to the authorities about the matter, but the Eliada Orphanage can’t afford to get into trouble by not making report of births at Faith Cottage.

Yours very truly,

J.G. Merrimon



 – Asheville Bar Association 1898 –

Asheville Bar Association ca. 1898. James G. Merrimon is standing 2nd from left.

Asheville, N.C. Bar Association in 1898. James G. Merrimon is standing in the back row, 2nd from left.


This entry was posted in Inside Eliada Orphanage and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to “To Protect and Defend” – The Legal Maneuverings of James G. Merrimon – by Clifford B. Davids

  1. Stephanie says:

    Wow! What a story! Thanks for sharing it.

  2. Robin Richardson Gilbert says:

    Serving the community in this way and doing it without acknowledgement gives us an insight into the big heart of James Merrimon. Defense of those who cannot defend themselves is always commendable.

  3. Alice says:

    It’s gratifying to read these tales of good people “doing good for its own sake.” More and more–or am I getting too old to see it–this seems to be a diminishing quality the more “enlightened” we get.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s